Kevin Barrett will be
interviewing Paul Levy on Monday, June 4th "The Dynamic Duo" 3-5 pm CT,
http://gcnlive.com Network 2.
BREAKING THE
VOW OF SILENCE
by Paul Levy www.awakeninthedream.com.
Certain events play out in our individual lives that reflect back to us
situations that are happening in the collective life of our nation or world.
One such event happened many years ago in the very synagogue in which I was
Bar-Mitzvahed. In what today seems like a dream, I was with my parents on
the holiest night of the entire Jewish year, “Kol Nidre”, the night before
“Yom Kippur”, the day of atonement. I probably hadn’t been to a synagogue
since my Bar-Mitzvah, which was years before. For the sermon, the rabbi gave
an impassioned talk about how everybody hates the Jews, and that we all
needed to band together against the world. His words were filled with hatred
and venom. He was literally preaching fear and separation. His vision had
nothing to do with love and compassion, and was certainly not based in
wisdom.
I was outraged by the rabbi’s talk. Much to my dismay, when I expressed my
feelings to my parents, they not only felt differently but also were very
angry with me for having the nerve to be critical of their rabbi. They felt
that I was being dis-respectful and sacrilegious by questioning the wisdom
of the rabbi, who was, after all, the leader of their congregation.
A couple of months later, the rabbi got fired. Why? It was because he was
consistently giving fear-inducing and hate-filled talks to his congregation.
My parents told me about the rabbi being fired, and asked me, totally
incredulous “How did you know”?
The underlying, unconscious psychological process that played out between my
parents and the rabbi is very revealing, in that it is isomorphic (similar
in structure) with what is playing out in our country today with people who
are unquestioningly supporting the Bush regime and its criminal policies.
Though the overwhelming majority of Americans now see through the current
administration’s web of lies, there are still enough people who, like my
parents blindly supporting the rabbi, either continue to unquestioningly
support Bush in his madness, or recognizing the madness, remain silent. Each
of these reactions allows the madness to enact itself unabated. The
underlying psychological process that played out with the rabbi and his
congregation was like a fractal that is presently reiterating itself en
masse in our country as well as in numerous permutations throughout the
world. Contemplating what was being symbolically revealed in the process
with the rabbi can help us understand how to better deal with the madness
that is currently being acted out in the body politic of our nation and our
world at large.
Because the rabbi was an unquestioned authority figure who was assumed by my
parents to know what he was talking about, they fell under his spell. In
blindly believing what the rabbi was saying, they naively invested their own
power into his hands. In doing so, they forfeited their own right to think
for themselves, to see out of their own eyes, to have their own experience,
and gave it away to the rabbi, who gladly accepted all the donations of his
follower’s minds. The rabbi then abused his rank, privilege, power and
authority, as he manipulated the compliant minds of his congregation in
order to feed his paranoid delusions. He was creating a dream of fear,
hatred, separation, and violence, and was enlisting all of the followers he
could entice.
For some reason, my parents weren’t able to recognize the craziness – and
malevolence - of what the rabbi was doing. They had projected their own
inner fantasy image of a positive leader and authority figure who could
guide them wisely and protect them from evil onto the rabbi. In the process,
my parents became entranced by their own hallucination of who they imagined
the rabbi was, and had become convinced that their inner imagination was
objectively true. Bewitched by their own unconscious projections, my parents
weren’t seeing the rabbi as he truly was, as if they were suffering from a
form of psychological blindness. Anyone who questioned their delusion was
experienced as a threat and demonized.
In unthinkingly trusting and following the rabbi, my parents’ critical
faculty of discernment, of being able to tell the difference between fantasy
and reality, had been disabled. Strangely, there was no talking to my
parents about this situation with reasoning or logic. Any evidence which was
contrary to my parent’s projections was either ignored and dismissed out of
hand, as if it didn’t exist, or perversely integrated into their psyche to
further confirm and validate the very projection that these facts actually
disproved (this is also a perfect description of a dynamic which occurs in
the minds of people who are supporting Bush in his madness).
Like a hypnotist, the rabbi had “captivated” a part of my parent’s
self-reflective awareness, “hooking” my parents through their unconscious
blind spot. Like a black magician in disguise, the rabbi had preyed on,
played into, worked with, and fed off of my parent’s needs and fears so as
to drain their power and co-dependently entangle them in his web of deceit.
Like my parents, the rest of the congregation that supported the rabbi were
also suffering from a form of psychological blindness, as if they had become
infected with a contagious psychic epidemic, a collective madness. I don’t
mean to be impolite when I say this, but is there a more apt way to describe
people who, cult-like, are following a deranged person?
In supporting the rabbi in his deluded world-view, my parents were literally
spellbound in fear, which was freely offered in abundance by the rabbi. Once
they gave away their power to the rabbi, what kept them stuck in denial was
the overwhelming painfulness of the shock that would necessarily ensue if
they were to see how they had given away their power to someone who was
mis-using their trust. They then became invested in sustaining their denial
so as to protect themselves from the awfulness of consciously experiencing
the lie that they had been living, a dis-illusion-ment that would have been
“too much” for them to bear. Seeing the truth of their situation would have
been so overwhelmingly traumatic that it had built into it a
counter-incentive to fully experience itself, which the rabbi continually
strengthened by creating guilt, fear – and terror - so as to keep his flock
in line.
TWO SIDES OF
THE SAME COIN
To understand
the underlying psychological process that was being unconsciously played out
in this scenario, it is important to realize that the psychological
blindness that my parents had fallen into cannot be contemplated separately
from the figure of the rabbi. In their mutual interaction, the roles of my
parents on the one hand, and the rabbi on the other are intimately linked
and bound together. Their roles don’t exist in static isolation from each
other but rather, in dynamic co-relation to each other. These two roles
never exist one without the other, as they are always found together,
simultaneously and reciprocally co-arising in the same moment, inseparably
united parts of a deeper process. To say this differently: my parents and
the rabbi are aspects of a deeper process that is playing itself out, and
revealing itself, through their interplay. To see this is to have an
expansion of consciousness in which we snap out of arbitrarily and
artificially thinking that we exist separate from each other, and get into
focus and feel into the deeper, underlying unified and unifying field of
consciousness which connects us and is giving shape to and in-forming what
is playing out in our world.
The rabbi had fallen under a self-created spell in which he had entranced
himself to think that the enemy was outside of himself. He had projected his
own shadow, his own darkness outside of himself, where the dreamlike
universe simply supplied all the evidence he needed to prove to himself the
seemingly objective truth of his projections in a self-generated,
self-confirming feedback loop that was of the nature of a self-fulfilling
prophecy. For example, there really are people who want to destroy Israel,
but being unconsciously identified with the role of the passive and
righteous victim, the rabbi didn’t realize the role that he, or the state of
Israel, collaboratively play in evoking the very response from others to
which they then react (please see my article Middle East Madness
http://awakeninthedream.com/mideast.html).
Entranced by his own mind, the rabbi was relating to an inner, spiritual
problem as if it existed outside of himself. In splitting off from and
projecting out his shadow, the rabbi was reacting against an enemy that he
himself was actively calling forth. This is a very peculiar form of madness
that is all too common in our world today.
When, like the rabbi,
one falls into the depraved state of believing one’s own lies, a certain
charisma is emanated that is very charming and convincing to people who are
not sufficiently in touch with themselves to have developed their own
“center” of discrimination and are therefore highly suggestible. The rabbi’s
delusion had a sufficient energy charge or field-of-force to attract, like
iron filings aligning themselves around a magnet, members of the
congregation into his viewpoint. Like my parents, other worshipers in the
synagogue, in agreeing with the rabbi’s locating the evil outside of
themselves, had created a very convenient receptacle to seemingly get rid of
and project out their own darkness. This process safeguarded them from
having to look at and thereby deal with the darkness within themselves.
Having an enemy to collectively scapegoat and project the shadow onto was a
great relief, though the fact that this process was based on a lie and was
guaranteed to ultimately create nothing but guilt, fear, and violence went
unnoticed by the members of the congregation. Rather they felt united in
self-righteousness, convinced by their mutually reinforcing delusions that
the evil was to be found outside of themselves. By collectively projecting
out their shadow, the rabbi and his followers had become unconsciously
possessed by the very shadow they were fighting against in the outside
world. Fighting against one’s own reflected shadow on the world stage is not
only a battle that can never be won; it is nothing other than madness
itself.
By supporting the rabbi in his paranoia, my parents and the congregation
were unwittingly feeding the rabbi’s madness in a self-perpetuating feedback
loop that simultaneously reinforced their childish need to give away their
power and have someone protect them. By giving away their power to the
rabbi, they became like children dependent on a parental authority figure.
By giving away their power and following the rabbi, they actually confirmed
the rabbi’s delusions, reinforcing his conviction that he must be a real
leader, as people were, in fact, following him.
The rabbi and his congregation were joined together in a co-dependent and
pathological feedback loop that had developed enough momentum or energy to
continually self-generate, like a Frankenstein monster, an autonomous life
of its own. As if enclosed in a bubble, the rabbi and the congregation
became seemingly cut off and separate from others, as well as dis-connected
from any reflection or co-evolutionary, in-forming influences from the
outside world. A situation of “group narcissism” was created between the
rabbi and his followers, as they fed into and off of each other’s
unconscious, narcissistic wounds, needs and fears. Avoiding self-reflection
at all costs, they reciprocally reinforced and colluded in each other’s
unconscious madness. An impenetrable field of un-consciousness became
conjured up around them which literally resisted self-reflective
consciousness. When this situation happens in a family, a community, a
nation, or a species, it is nothing other than a form of collective
psychosis (see my book The Madness of George W. Bush: A Reflection of our
Collective Psychosis; to see the first chapter, click
http://awakeninthedream.com/georgew.html).
When the rabbi and his
congregation are seen as an interconnected, whole system, there is
recognized to be a certain “stasis,” or non-fluidity to the system’s
dynamics. The system was not organically growing and evolving by allowing
other voices to be heard, but had a self-reinforcing rigidity to its
structure. In any system like this, there is, however, at each and every
moment a potentially novel role in the field which can spontaneously emerge
within the system and “catalyze” (which in chemistry means to “hasten a
reaction”) a change in the entire system.
In our example of the rabbi and his followers, this role in the system
manifested itself when the people who saw what was getting destructively
acted out in the community broke the vow of silence, connected with each
other, accessed their inherent power, and then mobilized themselves by
speaking up and acting in a way that made a difference. From the point of
view of the whole, interrelated system, this new voice was the instrument
through which the system evolved and autopoetically recreated itself into a
higher-order of coherence, integration, health, and wholeness.
The key to up-leveling the system and breaking the spell – in this case,
when the rabbi got fired – was when a “tipping point” was reached and enough
people in the community, a certain critical mass, saw the abuse that was
happening and, as if in a play or a dream, stepped into their roles as
empowered agents of change and collectively acted. Like T cells uniting to
fight a cancer in the body politic, they joined together as one voice,
activated their inherent power and authority as the true body of the
synagogue, and co-operatively configured and organized themselves so as to
resolve the underlying dysfunction in their community.
A DREAMING
PROCESS
Seen as a
dreaming process – in which the outer situation, just like a dream, is
expressing the inner state of the psyche – the rabbi was “dreamed up” into
fully materialized form as an expression of an unconscious process that
existed within each member of the congregation and vice versa. Becoming
caught in the spell that the rabbi was casting was ultimately of the
congregation’s own making, their own “doing” (which is the meaning of the
word “karma”), as their dis-empowered situation was an outer expression of
their inner state of unconsciousness. Their subservient, sheep-like
condition was a state in which they were actually victimizing themselves,
and for which they were ultimately responsible.
From the dreaming point of view, in embodying a figure who abused his
position of power, the rabbi was getting dreamed up to reflect back to the
congregation their dis-association from their own God-given power. An
externalized reflection of an inner process, the rabbi stepped into a role
and became a living embodiment of the figure who exists in potential inside
not only each member of the congregation, but ourselves as well. Revealing
an archetypal figure who exists deep within the collective unconscious of
humankind, the rabbi is re-presenting the inner/outer figure who at each and
every moment tries to “entrance” us to give away our power. This figure’s
attempt to deceive us is an expression of its own fear, its own lack, and
the extent of its own self-deception.
When we lack insight, connection, and fluency with our own power, we
invariably constellate our power to turn against us, both internally and in
the seemingly outer world. From the dreaming point of view, the rabbi was
simply getting dreamed up to play out a role that existed in the field; if
this particular person wasn’t around to play this role, “central casting”
would simply send someone else. The rabbi and the congregation were
colluding with and enabling each other to enact an unconscious, collective
decision to abrogate the community’s power to creatively and consciously
invent their world.
Seen symbolically, the outer situation with the rabbi actually helped
activate the congregation’s intrinsic power, which clearly hadn’t been
consciously realized up until then, otherwise the figure of the rabbi would
not have been dreamed up to abuse his power in the first place.
Contemplating this situation as a dreaming process, the figure of the rabbi
is a secret ally, his secret being secret even to himself, as through his
abuse of power he is unwittingly helping - make that demanding - the
congregation to connect with their genuine power (though his “help” to the
congregation was not in the way he imagined).
Once a sufficient number of people in the congregation snapped out of their
spell and saw the rabbi’s madness, which they were only able to do if they
themselves had stepped into sanity, they were able to collectively act and
remove the rabbi from his position of power. Just like a dream, an inner
change in the consciousness of the congregation become reflected in the
outer world, as their inner realization was creatively expressed in their
outer situation by skillful action. The fundamental change originated from
an inner transformation, which was then acted upon, and given shape and form
in the outside world. Incarnating our inner realization in the outside world
is the very act which in turn further stimulates our inner realization,
which then makes us more able to effect change in the outside world, ad
infinitum. This is a positive, “creative” feedback loop in which, instead of
continuing to unconsciously destroy each other, our world, and ourselves, we
can connect with and empower each other through the open-heart of lucid
awareness and consciously create the world in which we want to live.
It is important to emphasize: It is not enough just to see what is going on
and do nothing. The outer world becomes the medium or canvas, so to speak,
in which we actualize and make real our inner realization, as the two, the
inner and the outer, are recognized to be interconnected reflex-ions of each
other and inseparable aspects of a greater whole. We deepen our inner
realization by expressing it in the outer world. Reciprocally, we change the
outer world by deepening our inner realization.
FINDING OUR
VOICE IS TO WAKE UP
The situation
with the rabbi and his congregation is analogous to the situation in our
country with George Bush and those who see his abuse and remain silent. It
should be noted that the problem in the congregation wasn’t resolved by
convincing people like my parents, who having taken the rabbi’s toxic bait
hook, line, and sinker had become fixated on a point of view that lacked
reflective awareness, as if frozen in trauma. Just like it was futile for me
to try to convince my parents of their delusion, we are wasting our creative
energy if we attempt to convince people who are following Bush of how they
are following a wolf in sheep’s clothing. This is like trying to convince a
mad person of their madness, which if we persist in our efforts is an
expression of our own madness (i.e., our lack of insight into the nature of
the situation that we are trying to address). On the contrary, the situation
in the community got healed when enough people who saw the abuse broke
through their inertia and resistance and courageously spoke up in a way that
made a difference.
An abuser in a family system such as a spiritual community or a nation can
only get away with perpetrating abuse if enough people collude with the
abuse by staying silent. Remaining silent in the presence of abuse is to
marginalize our own power and unwittingly nourish the unconscious culture
which allows the abuse to flourish. Connecting with each other, investing in
the power of our collective voice and speaking up as one is the leverage
point through which we can intervene in the existing system so as to
transform it.
Abuse can only take place if enough people are silent about it, which is to
say that those who are silent about the abuse are complicit in it. Evil can
only play itself out without restraint when good people see what is
happening and do nothing. Staying silent in the presence of abuse, though
seemingly a passive role, is to unwittingly play an active role enabling our
own victimization.
Just like in the situation with the rabbi, however, when a critical mass of
people who see the evil that is playing out through our government come
together and break the vow of silence and act, they step out of the role of
helpless victims who are enabling and calling forth the abuse, and empower
themselves to transform the dynamics of the entire system. It is said that
the deepest place in hell is reserved for people who, seeing evil being
acted out, stay silent, not wanting to rock the boat. Presently, our ship of
state, to point out the obvious, is sinking from not being “rocked” enough.
To quote the late Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., “Our lives begin to end the
day we become silent about things that matter”.
Paul
Levy
is an artist and a spiritually-informed political activist. A pioneer in the
field of spiritual awakening, he is a healer in private practice, assisting
others who are also awakening to the dream-like nature of reality. He is the
author of “The Madness of George Bush: A Reflection of Our Collective
Psychosis,” which is available at his website
www.awakeninthedream.com.
Please feel free to pass this article along to a friend if you feel so
inspired. You can contact Paul at
paul@awakeninthedream.com;
he looks forward to your reflections.
© 2007 Paul Levy
Please
Support MUJCA-NET MUJCA-NET needs your support. We are a
non-profit organization and the scale of our activities depends
entirely on your generosity. We would like to get copies of David
Griffin's two 9/11 books (see above) into the hands of every
religious leader in America. And we would like to push 9/11 truth
onto the front pages of every newspaper in America. But we can't do
it without your help. If you would like to donate to MUJCA-NET,
click here.
TOP
|